Français
Graphic
Monday 23 January 2017

EU Emission Trading System: European Parliament puts a cap on local investments in "Modernisation Fund"

The EU Emission Trading System (ETS), a key tool of EU climate policy and the world’s largest carbon trading instrument, is currently being reformed for the period of 2021-2030. The European Parliament (EP) will adopt its ETS position on February 15th. According to its report, the Parliament plans to cap the share of local investments in the ETS Modernisation Fund. This funding instrument uses 2% of the ETS pollution permits revenue to support 10 Central and Eastern European Member States in their energy transition. Throughout 2016, Energy Cities had strongly advocated for a removal of this local energy investment barrier.

As the energy system is set to become more decentralised, the lion’s share of investments will need to happen on the local level – e.g. to speed up the energy efficient renovation of buildings, the uptake of demand management for consumers, the deployment of new technologies like blockchain and so on. Regardless of this trend, the European Parliament will put a 10% threshold on local energy investments within the ETS Modernisation Fund. How is that possible?

Cities and NGOs working hard for a fairer and locally-driven Modernisation Fund

Energy Cities attempted to remove this local energy investment barrier through its advocacy work in 2016. Through our “5 recommendations for a sensible use of the Modernisation Fund”, we urged this fund to finance small-scale projects without limitation, as the decentralisation of the future “modern” energy system has to be driven by strong local investments.

On the 20th of June 2016, together with the environmental NGOs CEE Bankwatch Network, Counter Balance and Change Partnership, we called upon the Council of Ministers to earmark the use of the Modernisation Fund for local energy projects. Through subsequent interventions at stakeholder conferences in Brussels and beyond, we worked to make the Modernisation Fund fairer and fit for local investment needs in Central and Eastern Europe.

Unfortunately, the European Parliament has maintained the cap on local energy investments in the ETS Modernisation Fund in its positioning. It has not changed this detrimental proposal from the EU Commission to financing the locally-driven energy transition.

The EU ETS context

The objective of the EU ETS is to put a price on carbon and implement strong emission cuts through a limited “right to pollute” (through emission allowances) for European industries. However, the ETS has not been able to deliver on its promises so far: the system provides too many free pollution permits to industries and allows them to make lucrative profits worth billions of Euros. Moreover, its price on carbon (around €5) is too low to put EU countries on the pathway of their Paris Agreement commitments. According to an OECD analysis, the carbon price should be at least six times higher to deliver strong emission cuts.

It is against this background that the European Parliament, together with the Council of Ministers, are aiming to reform the ETS as a pillar of EU climate policy for the period of 2021-2030. But the overly complex ETS is considered to be a hot potato for parliamentarians (MEPs), which is why the major parties (European People’s Party, Socialists & Democrats, the liberal party ALDE) refused to lead this file through the EU legislative process.

Finally, the Eurosceptic European Conservatives & Reformists party (ECR) agreed to take on the ETS dossier. Its Scottish MEP Ian Duncan, member of the EP environment committee, was tasked at the end of 2015 with preparing the Parliament’s position on the ETS reform, following a legislative proposal from the EU Commission’s Directorate-General for Climate Action.

The Modernisation Fund on the sidelines of the ETS debate

The ETS debate in 2016 hovered mostly around the rate of free pollution permits for industries, steeper and faster emission cuts to put the EU on the Paris Agreement trajectory, and the inclusion of additional industries (e.g. shipping) in the EU ETS.

The ETS Modernisation Fund was remarkably absent from the debate. This new crucial funding instrument will use 2% of ETS pollution permits (allowances) to support Poland, Czech Republic, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Slovakia, Croatia, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in "meeting the high investment needs relating to energy efficiency and the modernisation of their energy systems" between 2021 and 2030. It is bound to generate some €8 billion for these Member States in total, and will be divided among them according to a quota system that takes into account their GDP and their carbon emissions.

Already in the legislative proposal of the EU Commission’s Directorate-General for Climate Action from July 2015, the number of local investments to be financed through the Modernisation Fund has been limited. The 10 eligible Member States in Central and Eastern Europe mentioned before were only allowed to use 10% of their fund share to finance small-scale investments in energy efficiency and the modernisation of their energy systems.

The Way forward

The European Parliament still has time until its ETS plenary vote on the 15th of February in Strasbourg to make a U-turn on this issue. This would highly benefit local authorities in the 10 Central and Eastern European target countries of the Modernisation Fund, by allowing to channel much-needed additional funds into local climate action.

The European Parliament has shown in other areas of the ETS that it can be a driver of a sustainable and fair energy transition. It has stipulated that the Modernisation Fund cannot “contribute to new coal-fired energy generation nor increase coal dependency”, which is an important step forward in divesting from dirty energy sources and reinvesting into future-proof, sustainable ones.

Moreover, the EP has proposed that as of the 1st of January 2021, 2% of ETS auctioning revenues (over €200 million) shall be used to establish a “Just Transition Fund”, which shall support carbon-intensive regions in e.g. re-training their workers, support local business creation and develop a new local (energy) economy that provides new perspectives to its participants. The involvement of local social partners is set a key criterion for projects to get funding from this “Just Transition Fund”, and no limitation is defined for financing small-scale projects.

Following the promising example of the “Just Transition Fund”, Energy Cities calls upon the European Parliament to remove its cap on local investments in the Modernisation Fund, and play an enabling role in supporting and accelerating the locally-driven energy transition!

© Cover photo: Managenergy.net



by David Donnerer on 23 January 2017 / 521 visits




Related articles for EU policies / Politiques de l’UE

Conference countdown: Last week to register for #stuttgart2017!
by Miriam Eisermann on 10 avril 2017 /


Join us in Stuttgart and learn from your peers in 40 interactive sessions!
by Blandine Pidoux on 9 mars 2017 /


Un Conseil politique de villes pour diriger la Convention des Maires en Europe
by Floriane Cappelletti on 13 février 2017 /


A Political Board of Cities to steer the EU Covenant of Mayors
by Floriane Cappelletti on 13 February 2017 /


Energy Cities presents a brighter, local State of the Energy Union !
by Alix Bolle on 1 February 2017 /


Système d’échange des quotas d’émission de l’UE : le Parlement européen plafonne les investissements locaux éligibles au « Fonds pour la modernisation »
by David Donnerer on 24 January 2017 /


EU Emission Trading System: European Parliament puts a cap on local investments in "Modernisation Fund"
by David Donnerer on 23 January 2017 /


Une feuille de route 2050 (et autres résultats) du projet "Post-carbon cities of tomorrow"
by Blandine Pidoux on 17 janvier 2017 /


An EU Roadmap 2050 (and other results) from the "Post-carbon cities of tomorrow" project
by Blandine Pidoux on 17 janvier 2017 /


Democracy, Decentralisation, Divestment: '3D screening' of the EU Energy Package
by Alix Bolle on 30 November 2016 /


Convention des Maires: Faire des villes des acteurs clés des politiques climat-énergie en Europe
by David Donnerer on 29 November 2016 /


Covenant of Mayors: Transforming Cities into key EU Climate and Energy Actors
by David Donnerer on 29 November 2016 /


#100%ENR - Piste 2 : Tisser de nouveaux partenariats urbain-rural
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 17 novembre 2016 /


La Convention des Maires et Compact of Mayors lancent la plus grande coalition mondiale de villes engagées dans la lutte contre le changement climatique
by Floriane Cappelletti on 24 juin 2016 /


EU Covenant of Mayors and Compact of Mayors launch largest global coalition of cities committed to fighting climate change
by Floriane Cappelletti on 24 June 2016 /


EU Emission Trading System: Our 5 recommendations for a sensible use of the "Modernisation Fund"
by David Donnerer on 19 April 2016 /


Performance énergétique des bâtiments : Les villes finlandaises soutiennent la campagne Display et demandent des règles claires concernant la certification volontaire européenne
by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 1er avril 2016 /


Energy performance label: Finnish cities support the Display label and call for clearer rules for the voluntary EU scheme
by Ian Turner, Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 31 March 2016 /


Review of Energy Efficiency Directive: strengthen the local energy savings potential
by David Donnerer on 9 February 2016 /


L'Union européenne entre les mains des Pays-Bas : un semestre d'opportunités !
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 26 janvier 2016 /


The EU in Dutch hands: A semester of opportunities!
by Miriam Eisermann on 26 January 2016 /


Local elected leaders urge European Commission to reshape energy governance architecture
by Alix Bolle on 16 November 2015 /


New Covenant of Mayors for Climate & Energy: EU Institutions strengthen alliance with cities
by Floriane Cappelletti on 16 October 2015 /


Nouvelle Convention des Maires pour le Climat et l'Energie : alliance villes / institutions européennes renforcée
by Floriane Cappelletti on 16 octobre 2015 /


The new EU Energy Market Design: how local authorities could get better access
by Miriam Eisermann on 8 October 2015 /


EU after-summer policy wrap-up
by Miriam Eisermann on 5 October 2015 /


EU Smart Cities Agenda should push for an energy transition with cities and their citizens at the core
by Floriane Cappelletti on 21 September 2015 /


Launch of the largest ever consultation on the future of the Covenant of Mayors
by Floriane Cappelletti on 29 July 2015 /


Plantons le décor... du débat sur la sécurité énergétique au Parlement européen
by Alix Bolle on 19 mai 2015 /


Setting the scene: The European Parliament’s debate on energy security
by Alix Bolle on 19 May 2015 /


Juncker Plan: European Parliament decides to support local energy efficiency projects!
by Alix Bolle on 15 April 2015 /


L'Union de l'énergie partiellement éclipsée par les "Nations de l'énergie"
by Floriane Cappelletti on 20 mars 2015 /


EIB should increase its focus on energy efficiency and renewables at local level
by Admin on 19 mars 2015 /


Reporterre : Une minute, une question à Claire Roumet
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 13 mars 2015 /


"Nous avons besoin de votre énergie positive" : le Vice-Président de la Commission européenne rencontre les maires d'Energy Cities
by Floriane Cappelletti on 10 mars 2015 /


"We need your positive energy": EU Commission Vice President Šefčovič meets Energy Cities mayors
by Alix Bolle on 9 March 2015 /


EEFIG report identifies ways to drive new finance for energy efficiency investments
by Floriane Cappelletti on 27 February 2015 /


L'Union de l'énergie ne peut pas fonctionner sans les villes et les citoyens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 26 février 2015 /


Energy Union – It can’t work without cities and citizens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 26 February 2015 /


L"Union européenne de l'énergie" ne peut ignorer certaines réalités
by Blandine Pidoux on 5 janvier 2015 /


The « Energy Union » should be grounded in today’s reality
by Miriam Eisermann on 5 January 2015 /




Related articles for Financing & Economy / Financement & Economie

#Stuttgart2017 Final programme online!
by Blandine Pidoux on 31 March 2017 /


Just released! Two new guidebooks on financing the energy renovation of public and residential buildings
by Blandine Pidoux on 21 February 2017 /


EU Emission Trading System: European Parliament puts a cap on local investments in "Modernisation Fund"
by David Donnerer on 23 January 2017 /


Carbon credits: think local !
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 21 November 2016 /


Guest Article - "Energising the Sustainable Economy", by Andrea Crump (London Borough of Sutton)
by on 15 November 2016 /


Le prêt vert bruxellois : une autre incitation pour encourager les citoyens de Bruxelles à rénover leur logement
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 18 octobre 2016 /


The Brussels Green Loan: another incentive encouraging Brussels citizens to energy retrofit their homes
by Jana Cicmanova on 11 October 2016 /


Riga met en place un dispositif de soutien pour la rénovation de 6 000 logements
by Floriane Cappelletti, Jana Cicmanova on 1er juillet 2016 /


Riga to support the energy renovation of 6,000 houses
by Jana Cicmanova on 1 July 2016 /


Efficacité énergétique et financement ESCO à Niš
by David Donnerer on 15 juin 2016 /


Energy Efficiency and ESCO financing: Niš LE(A)DS the way
by David Donnerer on 15 June 2016 /


Le Fonds Climat d'Almada devient renouvelable
by Floriane Cappelletti on 7 juin 2016 /


Almada's Less Carbon Climate Fund becomes revolving
by Jana Cicmanova on 7 June 2016 /


The Udine Climate Fund: another step towards a sustainable energy city
by Jana Cicmanova on 23 May 2016 /


#Bornova2016 - Remunicipalising energy services: why and how?
by Floriane Cappelletti on 6 May 2016 /


Marché européen de quotas d'émissions : Nos 5 recommandations pour une utilisation judicieuse du "Fonds de Modernisation'
by Béatrice Alcaraz, David Donnerer on 19 avril 2016 /


A Stuttgart, les propriétaires de maisons individuelles peuvent bénéficier d'un pack rénovation "clé-en-main"
by Floriane Cappelletti on 31 mars 2016 /


In Stuttgart, private home owners can enjoy 'care-free' energy renovation package
by Floriane Cappelletti on 31 March 2016 /


Energy-renovation of houses : In Bordeaux Metropole, 85% of households fit requirements for a dedicated bank loan !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 17 March 2016 /


Rénovation énergétique du secteur résidentiel : à Bordeaux Métropole, 85% des foyers sont éligibles pour un prêt dédié !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 17 mars 2016 /


UK cities react against the government attack on their freedom to divest
by Rémi Collombet-Gourdon on 19 February 2016 /


La ville portugaise d'Águeda crée un Fonds local pour l'Efficacité Energétique et la Gestion de l'Eau
by Floriane Cappelletti on 11 février 2016 /


Portuguese city of Águeda sets up a local Fund for Energy and Water Efficiency
by Jana Cicmanova on 11 February 2016 /


Koprivnica crée le premier fonds renouvelable pour l'énergie de Croatie
by Floriane Cappelletti on 28 janvier 2016 /


Croatia's first local energy revolving fund is in Koprivnica!
by Jana Cicmanova on 28 January 2016 /


Frederikshavn, Danemark : Mobiliser l'épargne qui "dort" sur les comptes en banque des citoyens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 13 janvier 2016 /


Frederikshavn, Denmark: Mobilising savings ‘sleeping’ on citizens’ bank accounts
by Jana Cicmanova on 13 January 2016 /


Encourager les investissements au niveau local : analyse de projets ELENA-BEI dans Paris, Malmö, Barcelone, Bristol et la Région Bruxelles-Capitale
by Floriane Cappelletti on 8 juillet 2015 /


Unlocking investments in cities: Review of ELENA-EIB projects in Barcelona, Bristol, Malmö, Paris and Brussels-Capital Region
by Floriane Cappelletti on 8 July 2015 /


Financer l’énergie durable : comment s’y retrouver dans le labyrinthe européen
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 23 juin 2015 /


Financing sustainable energy: Finding your way
by Béatrice Alcaraz on 23 June 2015 /


La transition énergétique, véritable cocktail vitaminé pour l’économie locale !
by Floriane Cappelletti on 18 juin 2015 /


Energy transition, a true vitamin cocktail for the local economy!
by Floriane Cappelletti on 18 June 2015 /


Villes résilientes #3 : Développer de nouvelles approches financières
by Floriane Cappelletti on 1er juin 2015 /


Resilient cities #3: Developing new financing approaches
by Floriane Cappelletti on 1 June 2015 /


La BEI devrait accorder plus d'importance à l'efficacité énergétique et aux renouvelables au niveau local
by Floriane Cappelletti on 23 mars 2015 /


EIB should increase its focus on energy efficiency and renewables at local level
by Admin on 19 mars 2015 /


Le rapport de l'EEFIG identifie des moyens d'augmenter les investissements dans l'efficacité énergétique
by Floriane Cappelletti on 28 février 2015 /


EEFIG report identifies ways to drive new finance for energy efficiency investments
by Floriane Cappelletti on 27 February 2015 /


Le nouveau guide de la Convention des Maires aide les villes à identifier des opportunités de financement de leurs projets d'énergie durable
by Floriane Cappelletti on 5 février 2015 /


New Covenant of Mayors guide helps cities identify suitable funding opportunities for sustainable energy
by Floriane Cappelletti on 5 February 2015 /




The team

Blog Categories
Line
Last posts
Line
Archives
separator
You are here: Energy Cities, Local authorities in energy transition. > English > Blog

About
Association
Board of Directors
Members
Team
Jobs
Internships
Come and meet us
Position papers
Join
How to join
Why we joined
Actions
Initiatives & Campaigns
Projects
Past projects
Workshops
Webinars
Annual Conferences
Study Tours
Resources
Energy transition: our proposals
Best practices from members
Publications
e-libraries
EC INFO Magazine
Newsletter
Blog
MEDIA
Press releases
Articles
Communication tools

 
Addresses Energy Cities - Besançon Energy Cities - Bruxelles