Wednesday 30 November 2016

Democracy, Decentralisation, Divestment: '3D screening' of the EU Energy Package

How “3D compatible” is the newly released, 1200-page strong “clean energy for all Europeans” package released today by the European Commission? How much does it contribute to a system shift towards more prosperity, legitimacy and leadership on sustainable energy? In other words: how is legitimacy secured by Democratizing the energy system, empowering citizens and communities? How is prosperity brought about, by Divesting funding streams from fossil fuels and reDirecting them to activities creating local added value? How is true leadership – as the EU remains intent on being #1 on renewables - guaranteed by putting the right players in control and Decentralising not only the production but also the competences?

On the rhetoric, the package includes very positive language on each dimension of this 3D agenda for action. But as always, the devil is in the detail and a closer look at actual provisions provides a much bleaker picture.

What’s in the package?

What the Brussels bubble informally calls the “jumbo package” notably includes the overhaul of the EU electricity market design, the recast of the Renewables and Energy Efficiency Directives and a proposal for the governance of the Energy Union, ie the mechanism through which member states will be expected to contribute towards and report on the five pillars of (1) energy efficiency; (2) decarbonisation; (3) internal market; (4) research and innovation and (5) energy security.

Energy democracy, really?

A central message of the package talks about “securing a fair deal for energy consumers” - alongside putting energy efficiency first and making the EU world number one on renewables. Just looking at the semantics, it is regrettable that the reference is not on “energy citizens” instead, as active protagonists of the system change rather than passive market beneficiaries or contributors to enhanced flexibility. Energy citizens indeed, whether acting at individual or community level, are a key ally for Europe to achieve its ambition of becoming a renewable leader, with the potential to cover half of the bloc’s electricity demand by 2050.

The new set of legislations now enshrines the individual right to produce, consume and store one’s own energy, as well as sell any surplus to the grid. But apparent progress on certain provisions are quickly overshadowed by others, as the market design on the other hand foresees a phase out of so-called “priority dispatch”, which forces the grid to take power from renewables before other sources of energy. Changing this would penalize renewable energy investments, as they would be the first to be stopped in a situation of oversupply at the benefit of less flexible conventional plants. While large power companies might be able to withstand such a move, it poses a serious threat to the business model of smaller energy cooperatives.

© World Future Council

Decentralising production, but re-centralising decisions

The Commission has made it clear across the board: it wants its energy market and grid to be fit for increasing shares of decentralised generation. But while production is going more local, the decision-making architecture is becoming ever more centralised and top-down.
One key example of this worrying trend is the decision to create an official European body for Distribution System Operators (DSOs) allowing them to make their own rules and regulation over all aspects of grid planning, the so-called “network codes”. In effect, this body would provide greater influence to large incumbents – especially as many DSOs still hold conflict of interest links with power companies – while leaving little to no room for smaller players such as local energy companies.

As regards the proposed governance of the Energy Union, the new protagonists of the decentralised energy system are also left aside. Local authorities are only treated as part of a larger group of stakeholders to be consulted on the margins. Their contribution to energy security and grid stability is still underestimated, despite their key role in tapping local resources first, optimizing surplus electricity via power to gas or hydrogen options, storing heat through district heating networks, etc. Instead, the focus is still very narrowly put on interconnection of electricity markets, an important and complementary strategy but one that can sometimes prove less resilient than local solutions, as recent news have shown.

On a more upbeat note, the new energy efficiency directive provides positive political signal for more energy efficiency actions across cities with a 30% binding target at EU level, although the mechanisms to ensure compliance remain vague. New instruments such as the “Smart Finance for Smart Buildings” could help local authorities better reap the benefits of energy savings.

Money flowing the wrong way

The release of the package comes with the promise to create 900 000 jobs and pump €190bn into Europe’s economy, notably thanks to a prominent energy efficiency focus on the European Commission agenda.

On renewables and market design however, financial support is not heading in the right direction. On one hand, the European Commission puts an end to green support schemes such as feed in tariffs, leaving renewables hostage to market rules of competitive bidding. This new tendering logic risks marginalising community energy projects, as the latter might in some cases be forced to compete with large utilities, despite their greater socio-economic contributions to society.

On the other hand, the Commission preserves the Member States’ right to introduce so-called “capacity mechanisms”, a form of indirect subsidies to pay for conventional power plants to remain on stand by and provide back-up generation in case of supply shortage. Although not all fossil fuel plants will qualify for such payments, this old system logic might nonetheless contribute to overcapacity and thus discourage new investments in more sustainable alternatives. The failure to consider the full ranges of options is also due to the “electricity-only” bias of the market design legislation.

Energy Cities’ efforts as part of the coalition for community energy have nonetheless helped to draw attention on the manifold advantages of local projects. Indeed, the Electricity Market directive now states that such initiatives have managed “to deliver economic, social and environmental value to the community that goes beyond the mere benefits derived from the provision of energy services.” As the ball now rolls into the Council and European Parliament’s court, the next steps will be to make sure that good language comes with enforceable provisions.

by Alix Bolle on 30 November 2016 / 1364 visits

Related articles for EU policies / Politiques de l’UE

New publication out: Investment needs for the local energy transition
by David Donnerer on 6 May 2019 /

EU deal on Energy Union Governance enables local authorities to participate in designing national climate and energy futures
by David Donnerer on 20 June 2018 /

Ce que le prochain budget de l’UE apportera à la transition énergétique au niveau local
by David Donnerer on 31 mai 2018 /

What the next EU budget will bring for the local energy transition
by David Donnerer on 31 May 2018 /

When the EIB is learning from cities: more EU money for local energy?
by David Donnerer on 8 February 2018 /

New EU decision lifts key barrier to investing in energy efficiency projects
by David Donnerer on 21 September 2017 /

Energy Cities President meets Members of European Parliament to discuss role of cities in EU Energy Union governance
by David Donnerer on 13 July 2017 /

Call for best practices 100% REN
by Blandine Pidoux, Miriam Eisermann on 4 July 2017 /

Appel à bonnes pratiques 100% RES
by Blandine Pidoux, Miriam Eisermann on 4 juillet 2017 /

Horizon 2020 et Villes Intelligentes: Nos recommandations pour le programme de travail 2018-2020
by David Donnerer on 17 mai 2017 /

Horizon 2020 and Smart Cities: Our recommendations for the work-programme 2018-2020
by David Donnerer on 17 May 2017 /

Les Maires lancent un appel pour une réforme de l’Union européenne axée sur les citoyens.
by Blandine Pidoux on 3 mai 2017 /

Mayors launch call for citizen-oriented overhaul of the EU
by Blandine Pidoux on 3 May 2017 /

Quel avenir pour la politique européenne sur l’efficacité énergétique dans le cadre du "Clean Energy package" ?
by David Donnerer on 2 mai 2017 /

What prospects for EU energy efficiency policy with the Clean Energy Package?
by David Donnerer on 2 May 2017 /

Conference countdown: Last week to register for #stuttgart2017!
by Miriam Eisermann on 10 avril 2017 /

Join us in Stuttgart and learn from your peers in 40 interactive sessions!
by Blandine Pidoux on 9 mars 2017 /

Un Conseil politique de villes pour diriger la Convention des Maires en Europe
by Floriane Cappelletti on 13 février 2017 /

A Political Board of Cities to steer the EU Covenant of Mayors
by Floriane Cappelletti on 13 February 2017 /

Energy Cities presents a brighter, local State of the Energy Union !
by Alix Bolle on 1 February 2017 /

Système d’échange des quotas d’émission de l’UE : le Parlement européen plafonne les investissements locaux éligibles au « Fonds pour la modernisation »
by David Donnerer on 24 January 2017 /

EU Emission Trading System: European Parliament puts a cap on local investments in "Modernisation Fund"
by David Donnerer on 23 January 2017 /

Une feuille de route 2050 (et autres résultats) du projet "Post-carbon cities of tomorrow"
by Blandine Pidoux on 17 janvier 2017 /

An EU Roadmap 2050 (and other results) from the "Post-carbon cities of tomorrow" project
by Blandine Pidoux on 17 janvier 2017 /

Democracy, Decentralisation, Divestment: '3D screening' of the EU Energy Package
by Alix Bolle on 30 November 2016 /

Convention des Maires: Faire des villes des acteurs clés des politiques climat-énergie en Europe
by David Donnerer on 29 November 2016 /

Covenant of Mayors: Transforming Cities into key EU Climate and Energy Actors
by David Donnerer on 29 November 2016 /

#100%ENR - Piste 2 : Tisser de nouveaux partenariats urbain-rural
by Béatrice Karas on 17 novembre 2016 /

La Convention des Maires et Compact of Mayors lancent la plus grande coalition mondiale de villes engagées dans la lutte contre le changement climatique
by Floriane Cappelletti on 24 juin 2016 /

EU Covenant of Mayors and Compact of Mayors launch largest global coalition of cities committed to fighting climate change
by Floriane Cappelletti on 24 June 2016 /

EU Emission Trading System: Our 5 recommendations for a sensible use of the "Modernisation Fund"
by David Donnerer on 19 April 2016 /

Performance énergétique des bâtiments : Les villes finlandaises soutiennent la campagne Display et demandent des règles claires concernant la certification volontaire européenne
by on 1er avril 2016 /

Energy performance label: Finnish cities support the Display label and call for clearer rules for the voluntary EU scheme
by Ian Turner on 31 March 2016 /

Review of Energy Efficiency Directive: strengthen the local energy savings potential
by David Donnerer on 9 February 2016 /

L'Union européenne entre les mains des Pays-Bas : un semestre d'opportunités !
by Béatrice Karas on 26 janvier 2016 /

The EU in Dutch hands: A semester of opportunities!
by Miriam Eisermann on 26 January 2016 /

Local elected leaders urge European Commission to reshape energy governance architecture
by Alix Bolle on 16 November 2015 /

New Covenant of Mayors for Climate & Energy: EU Institutions strengthen alliance with cities
by Floriane Cappelletti on 16 October 2015 /

Nouvelle Convention des Maires pour le Climat et l'Energie : alliance villes / institutions européennes renforcée
by Floriane Cappelletti on 16 octobre 2015 /

The new EU Energy Market Design: how local authorities could get better access
by Miriam Eisermann on 8 October 2015 /

EU after-summer policy wrap-up
by Miriam Eisermann on 5 October 2015 /

EU Smart Cities Agenda should push for an energy transition with cities and their citizens at the core
by Floriane Cappelletti on 21 September 2015 /

Launch of the largest ever consultation on the future of the Covenant of Mayors
by Floriane Cappelletti on 29 July 2015 /

Plantons le décor... du débat sur la sécurité énergétique au Parlement européen
by Alix Bolle on 19 mai 2015 /

Setting the scene: The European Parliament’s debate on energy security
by Alix Bolle on 19 May 2015 /

Juncker Plan: European Parliament decides to support local energy efficiency projects!
by Alix Bolle on 15 April 2015 /

L'Union de l'énergie partiellement éclipsée par les "Nations de l'énergie"
by Floriane Cappelletti on 20 mars 2015 /

EIB should increase its focus on energy efficiency and renewables at local level
by Admin on 19 mars 2015 /

Reporterre : Une minute, une question à Claire Roumet
by Béatrice Karas on 13 mars 2015 /

"Nous avons besoin de votre énergie positive" : le Vice-Président de la Commission européenne rencontre les maires d'Energy Cities
by Floriane Cappelletti on 10 mars 2015 /

"We need your positive energy": EU Commission Vice President Šefčovič meets Energy Cities mayors
by Alix Bolle on 9 March 2015 /

EEFIG report identifies ways to drive new finance for energy efficiency investments
by Floriane Cappelletti on 27 February 2015 /

L'Union de l'énergie ne peut pas fonctionner sans les villes et les citoyens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 26 février 2015 /

Energy Union – It can’t work without cities and citizens
by Floriane Cappelletti on 26 February 2015 /

L"Union européenne de l'énergie" ne peut ignorer certaines réalités
by Blandine Pidoux on 5 janvier 2015 /

The « Energy Union » should be grounded in today’s reality
by Miriam Eisermann on 5 January 2015 /

The team

Blog Categories
Last posts
You are here: Energy Cities, Local authorities in energy transition. > English > BLOG

About us
In a nutshell
Privacy policy
EU Policy
How to join
Why we joined
Initiatives & Campaigns
Annual Conferences
Study Tours
Energy transition: our proposals
Best practices from members
EC INFO Magazine
Press releases
Communication tools

Addresses Energy Cities - Besançon Energy Cities - Bruxelles